| |
Original research
|
Peer reviewed
|
Acute and prolonged effects
of ammonia on hematological variables, stress responses, performance, and
behavior of nursery pigs
Efectos prolongados
y agudos del amonio en variables hematológicas, respuestas al estrés,
desempeño, y conducta en cerdos en destete
Effets aigus et
prolongés de l’ammoniaque sur des variables hématologiques,
les réponses au stress, les performances, et le comportement des
porcelets en pouponnières
E. von Borell,
PhD; A. Özpinar, PhD; K. M. Eslinger; A. L. Schnitz; Y. Zhao, PhD; F.
M. Mitloehner, PhD
EVB: Institute of
Agricultural and Nutritional Sciences, Martin-Luther-University Halle-Wittenberg,
Halle, Germany. AO: Western Institute for Food Safety and Security, University
of California, Davis, California. KME, YZ, FMM: Department of Animal Science,
University of California, Davis, California. Corresponding author: Dr
F. M. Mitloehner, One Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616–8521; Tel: 530-752-3936;
Fax 530-752-0175; E-mail: fmmitloehner@ucdavis.edu.
Cite as: von
Borell E, Özpinar A, Eslinger KM, et al. Acute and prolonged effects
of ammonia on hematological variables, stress responses, performance, and
behavior of nursery pigs. J Swine Health Prod. 2007;15(3):137–145.
Also
available as a PDF.
Summary
Objectives: To determine acute and prolonged effects of 35 and 50 ppm
concentrations of atmospheric ammonia (NH3) on welfare of weaned pigs.
Materials and methods: Two experiments were conducted using gas exposure
chambers to investigate prolonged effects (Experiment One; 19 days) and acute
effects (Experiment Two; 96 hours) of NH3. Each experiment included two studies:
exposure to NH3 at 0 and 35 ppm and at 0 and 50 ppm. In Experiment One, body
weight, hematological and metabolic variables, and serum cortisol and haptoglobin
were assessed, and behaviors were video-taped. In Experiment Two, serum cortisol
and haptoglobin and plasma tumor necrosis factor-α were measured.
Results: Absolute counts of white blood cells, lymphocytes, and monocytes
were greater in pigs exposed to 35 ppm NH3 than in controls (P < .05).
Serum haptoglobin was higher in pigs exposed to 50 ppm NH3 for 7 and 19 days
than in controls (P < .05). Serum cortisol concentrations were
greater in pigs exposed to 35 or 50 ppm NH3 for 19 days than in controls (P < .05).
Less feeding behavior was observed in pigs exposed to 50 ppm NH3 than in controls
(P < .05). In acute studies, serum cortisol concentrations were greater
in pigs exposed to NH3 than in controls (P < .05).
Implications: Under the conditions of these studies, prolonged exposure
to NH3 is associated with increases in absolute monocyte, lymphocyte, and neutrophil
counts and in serum cortisol and haptoglobin concentrations, but has no effect
on pig growth performance.
| Resumen
Objetivos: Determinar los efectos prolongados y agudos de concentraciones
de amonio atmosférico (NH3) en concentraciones de 35 y 50 ppm en el
bienestar de cerdos destetados.
Materiales y métodos: Se realizaron dos experimentos utilizando
cámaras de exposición a gas para investigar los efectos prolongados
(Experimento Uno; 19 días) y los efectos agudos (Experimento Dos; 96
horas) del NH3. Cada experimento incluyó dos estudios: exposición
al NH3 a 0 y 35 ppm y a 0 y 50 ppm. En el Experimento Uno, se valoraron el
peso corporal, las variables metabólicas y hematológicas, y el
cortisol y la haptoglobina en el suero, y se videograbaron los comportamientos.
En el Experimento Dos, se midieron el suero de cortisol, la haptoglobina, y
el factor-α del plasma de la necrosis del tumor.
Resultados: Los conteos absolutos de las células blancas de
la sangre, los linfocitos, y los monocitos fueron mayores en los cerdos expuestos
a 35 ppm de NH3 que en los controles (P < .05). La haptoglobina del
suero fue mayor en cerdos expuestos a 50 ppm de NH3 por 7 y 19 días
que en los controles (P <
.05). Las concentraciones de cortisol en suero fueron mayores en cerdos expuestos
a 35 o 50 ppm de NH3 por 19 días que en los controles (P < .05).
Se observó un comportamiento de menor consumo de alimento en cerdos
expuestos a 50 ppm de NH3 que en los controles (P < .05). En
estudios agudos, las concentraciones de cortisol en suero fueron mayores en
cerdos expuestos de manera aguda al NH3 que en los controles (P < .05).
Implicaciones: Bajo las condiciones de estos estudios, la exposición
prolongada al NH3 se relaciona con incrementos en los conteos absolutos de
monocitos, linfocitos, y neutrófilos y en las concentraciones de cortisol
y haptoglobina en suero, pero no tiene efecto en el desempeño de crecimiento
el cerdo.
| Resumé
Objectifs: Déterminer les effets aigus et prolongés de
concentrations de 35 et 50 ppm d’ammoniaque atmosphérique (NH3)
sur le bien-être de porcs sevrés.
Matériels et méthodes: Deux expériences ont été
effectuées en utilisant une chambre permettant l’exposition au
gaz pour étudier les effets prolongés (Expérience 1; 19
jours) et les effets aigus (Expérience 2; 96 heures) du NH3. Chaque
expérience comportait deux études: exposition au NH3 à des
concentrations de 0 et 35 ppm, et exposition à des concentrations de
0 et 50 ppm. Au cours de l’Expérience 1, on a mesuré le
poids corporel, des variables hématologiques et métaboliques,
et les concentrations sériques de cortisol et d’haptoglobine,
et enregistré les comportements sur bande vidéo. Lors de l’Expérience
2, on a mesuré le cortisol et l’haptoglobine sériques et
le facteur-α nécrosant de tumeurs.
Résultats: Les nombres absolus de leucocytes, lymphocytes, et
monocytes étaient plus élevés chez les porcs exposés à 35
ppm de NH3 que chez les porcs témoins (P <
.05). L’haptoglobine sérique était plus élevée
chez les porcs exposés à 50 ppm de NH3 pour 7 et 19 jours que
chez les témoins (P < .05). Les concentrations de cortisol
sérique étaient plus élevées chez les porcs exposés à 35
ou 50 ppm de NH3 pendant 19 jours que chez les témoins (P < .05).
Moins de comportements de prise de nourriture ont été observés
chez les porcs exposés à 50 ppm de NH3 que chez les témoins.
(P <
.05). Dans les études d’exposition aiguë,
les concentrations de cortisol sérique étaient plus élevées
chez les porcs exposés au NH3 que chez les témoins (P < .05).
Implications: Dans les conditions expérimentales de ces
études, une exposition prolongée au NH3 est associée avec
une augmentation absolue des comptes de monocyte, lymphocyte, et neutrophile
et des concentrations sériques de cortisol et d’haptoglobine,
mais aucun effet n’a été observé sur les performances
zootechniques des porcs.
|
Keywords: swine, ammonia,
welfare, performance, stress response
Search the AASV web site
for pages with similar keywords.
Received: December
5, 2005
Accepted: May
31, 2006
Despite the lack in understanding of acute and prolonged effects
of ammonia (NH3), it has been suggested that NH3 exposure increases
inflammatory, immune, and neuroendocrine stress responses in
pigs.1 The most common inflammatory pathway involves
induction of cytokines (eg, IL-1, IL-4, IL-6, and tumor necrosis
factor-α (TNF-α), which mediate and regulate immunity,
inflammation, and hematopoiesis in response to tissue
damage.2 Cytokines are produced de novo in response to
an immune stimulus. Atmospheric NH3 is believed to cause release of
cytokines by alveolar macrophages and neutrophils, constituting a
potent inflammatory response.3 The early phase of
inflammation is characterized by acute phase protein responses. An
increase in concentrations of acute phase proteins (eg,
haptoglobin) generally occurs during infection, injury, and tissue
destruction; thus, acute phase proteins are useful stress
indicators.4 High concentrations of haptoglobin and
cytokines, and elevated counts of total white blood cells (WBC),
macrophages, neutrophils, and lymphocytes, are generally viewed as
indicators of inflammatory or immunological responses to
stress.1 Serum cortisol, as a measure of the
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, is widely used to describe the
effect of a stressor on immune function.5 Previous
research has suggested that inflammatory stress correlates with
suboptimal feed intake and growth.6
Current recommendations established by the US Occupational
Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) on upper limits for NH3
concentrations in swine confinement buildings are mainly intended
to provide occupational exposure limits over an 8-hour period. The
OSHA threshold for permissible worker 8-hour exposure is 50 ppm,
and the short-term exposure limit (15 minutes) is 35
ppm.7 While these two exposure standards relate to human
health exposure, information on the effects of NH3 on animal
welfare is scarce, and no thresholds have been established in the
United States to date.8
The objectives of this study were to determine the effects of
acute and prolonged exposure to atmospheric NH3 at concentrations
of 35 and 50 ppm on welfare of recently weaned nursery pigs housed
under controlled experimental conditions in environmental chambers.
Welfare measurements included stress indices, hematological,
metabolic, and endocrine variables, and growth performance and
behavior.
Materials and methods
Animals, housing, and feeding
For each of four studies, male and female crossbred piglets
(Yorkshire × Hampshire) weaned at 19.2 ± 1.1 days of age were
distributed evenly by litter and gender into six pens (1.2 m × 1.2
m; four pigs per pen) in each of two chambers (24 pigs per study
per chamber, 12 males and 12 females per chamber). Pigs were
adapted to the housing conditions for 10 days after weaning, and
exposure studies began when they were on average 29 days old.
The research was conducted at the Swine Research Teaching and
Outreach Facility at the University of California, Davis, utilizing
two identical environmental exposure chambers, each measuring 10.7
m long × 4.8 m wide × 3.1 m high (159 m3). One chamber
(treatment chamber) was supplied with NH3 at concentrations of 35
and 50 ppm, and the other (control chamber) was supplied with fresh
air (0 ppm NH3). Each chamber ceiling had two inlet air ducts and
one outlet air duct. Fresh outside air (37.4 m3
per minute) was supplied through the inlet air ducts to each
chamber and the same quantity of chamber air exited from the outlet
air duct. Incoming air was unaltered except for heating or cooling.
Room temperatures in each chamber were automatically maintained at
22°C ± 2°C. The slatted chamber floor was hosed clean with water
once daily to remove excreta.
Each pen was equipped with a nipple waterer and a two-hole
feeder that allowed access for two to three pigs to feed at any
given time. In order to maintain ad libitum feed access, feeder
reservoirs were re-filled once daily with a pelleted,
corn-soy-based diet with 19% crude protein (as fed). Feed
ingredients (on a dry matter basis) were corn (58.3%), soybean
(26.5%), Akey Start 200 Base (Akey, Lewisburg, Ohio) (8%), fat
(5%), mono-dical phosphate (1.2%), limestone meal (0.9%), salt
(0.9%), and Tylan 40 (Elanco, Indianapolis, Indiana) (0.1%).
The University of California, Davis, Animal Care and Use
Committee approved these studies.
Study design
Two experiments were conducted as completely randomized designs
with pen as the experimental unit.9,10 Each experiment
included 48 pigs, with 24 pigs and six replications per chamber,
and four pigs per pen. Experimental design followed common
pathology and exposure studies in which the impact of two housing
environments for swine differing in pathological loads were
compared.11,12
In Experiment One, two 20-day studies were conducted, beginning
10 days post weaning (Day 0). Prolonged effects on welfare were
evaluated in groups of pigs exposed to atmospheric NH3 at 0 and 35
ppm in Study 1 and 0 and 50 ppm in Study 2. Blood samples and
individual body weights (BW) were obtained Day -1 (pre ammonia
exposure) and Days 7 and 19. Blood samples were obtained from all
24 pigs per chamber between 8:00 am and 9:00 am for cortisol,
haptoglobin, and TNF-α assays. One pig per pen was randomly
selected to be tested for hematology measures (n = 6). Behavior was
video-taped between 7 am and 7 pm on Days 2 and 18, when blood
samples were not collected, to ensure undisturbed behavior.
In Experiment Two, two 96-hour studies were conducted. Acute
effects on welfare were evaluated in groups of pigs exposed to
atmospheric NH3 at 0 and 35 ppm in Study 3 and at 0 and 50 ppm in
Study 4. Blood samples were collected from all 24 pigs per
treatment group at 72 hours before and 2, 8, 12, 24, 48, and 96
hours after ammonia exposure began, and six samples (one pig per
pen, as in Experiment One) were randomly selected for testing for
cortisol, haptoglobin, and TNF-α assays (n = 6)
Ammonia gas exposure
Before the experiments started, capability of the chambers to
produce uniform gas distribution was assessed. Therefore, gas
mixing characteristics were determined and found satisfactory using
sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) tracer gas, which was released through
the air inlet and measured in vertical and horizontal matrix
planes. Chambers had forced ventilation at 3.8
× 104 L per minutes, resulting in a chamber
residence time of approximately 6 minutes. The elevated NH3
concentration in the treatment chamber was achieved by mixing pure
anhydrous NH3 gas (99.9% ammonia purity) with the fresh inlet air.
The NH3 gas cylinder was located outside the treatment chamber and
connected to the incoming air duct using Teflon tubing. A regulator
controlled the delivery pressure, and a mass flow controller was
used to adjust and monitor the NH3 flow rate. Swagelok fittings
(Swagelok Company, Solon, Ohio) were used for all connections to
prevent potential leaks of NH3 in the gas delivery system. The pure
NH3 gas exited from the delivery tubing inside the inlet duct,
where NH3 mixed with fresh air.
To achieve 35 and 50 ppm NH3 concentrations inside the treatment
chamber, pure NH3 gas flow rates were 0.7 and 1.0 L per minute,
respectively. Concentration of NH3 was monitored inside the animal
pens at animal level using three instruments and methodologies. The
first instrument, a Draeger Pac III NH3 gas monitor (Draeger,
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; 1 ppm accuracy), was used three times per
day. The second instrument, a Pranalytica photoacoustic
spectroscopy monitor (Pranalytica, Santa Monica, California),
measured NH3 concentrations continuously at animal level as
described earlier by our laboratory.13 The third
instrument was a Dionex ICS90 ion chromatograph (Dionex, Sunnyvale,
California) using an acid impinger sampling method.13
For the latter method, air was sampled through Teflon tubing from
the animal pens into sampling trains containing sulfuric acid.
Atmospheric NH3 was trapped in the acid and analyzed in the
laboratory using ion chromatography. The acid impinger method was
conducted to confirm the Draeger Pac III and Pranalytica sensor
measurements (Experiment One, twice per week; Experiment Two, 10
hours after exposure began). The NH3 flow rate was fine-tuned to
keep the changes in NH3 concentration within 5% of the required
values.
Blood-sample collection and processing
Blood samples for both experiments were collected via puncture
of the anterior vena cava using evacuated blood collection tubes
and 20-gauge, 3.8-cm disposable needles. Pigs were individually
removed from the chamber and restrained on a bleeding table, and
blood was collected in < 1 minute per pig, minimizing the stress
associated with the procedure.
Whole blood samples from tubes containing sodium fluoride (for
determination of lactate and glucose) were mixed by inversion and
centrifuged (2500g for 5 minutes) within 15 minutes of
collection. The separated plasma samples were immediately
transported (on dry ice) to the laboratory for same-day
analysis.
Whole blood samples from tubes that contained EDTA were kept
cold on ice at 4°C and separated into two subsamples per pig. The
first subsample was transferred to the laboratory on ice at 4°C for
hematological measurements. The second subsample was centrifuged
(2500g for 5 minutes) within 30 minutes of collection, and
plasma was subdivided into two portions. The first plasma portion
was transported on dry ice directly to the laboratory for
metabolite analysis (ie, blood urea nitrogen [BUN], plasma NH3).
The second plasma portion was stored at -70°C for analysis of
TNF-α.
Whole blood samples for cortisol and haptoglobin determination
were placed on ice for 2 hours before centrifugation (2500g
at 4°C for 20 minutes) and the serum was stored at -70°C until
analysis.
Hematology assays were conducted on the day the samples were
collected. All frozen samples were thawed and assayed 2 days after
the animal experiments were completed.
Hematology, clinical chemistry, and plasma NH3 analyses
All metabolite and cell determination measures were conducted at
the Preclinical Research Service, Idexx Laboratories (West
Sacramento, California). Plasma BUN, glucose, lactate, and NH3
concentrations were measured using an enzymatic method on an auto
analyzer (Roche, Hitachi 717; Diamond Diagnostics, Holliston,
Massachusetts). An automated cell counter (Coulter Gen-S Bayer,
ADVIA 120 hematology analyzer; Diamond Diagnostics) was used for
platelet count, red blood cell count, hemoglobin, hematocrit, mean
corpuscular volume (MCV), mean corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH), mean
corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC), WBC count, and
absolute counts of neutrophils, lymphocytes, monocytes,
eosinophils, and basophils.
Assays for TNF-α, haptoglobin, and cortisol
Plasma levels of TNF-α were measured in duplicate using a
single commercial kit (swine-specific biotinylated monoclonal
antibody sandwich ELISA; Biosource International, Swine TNF-alpha;
Camarillo, California) according to the supplier’s
instructions as described.14 Serum haptoglobin
concentration was measured using a single commercial kit (Phase
range haptoglobin assay kit; Tridelta Development, Greystones,
Ireland) as described by Petersen et al.15 Serum
cortisol concentration was measured in duplicate using a
radioimmunoassay technique as previously described by Daley et
al.16 Interassay and intra-assay coefficients of
variation for TNF-α, haptoglobin, and cortisol were <
8%.
Behavior (Experiment One)
Two identical video systems (one per chamber) were installed to
allow for detailed analysis of behaviors. One HTC 65°C day-night
color camera per chamber (CCD image sensor, 380 TV lines, 1 lux
sensitivity; Inter-Pacific, Deerfield, Illinois) with wide angle
lens (CE F1.4/1.6–3.4 mm; Inter-Pacific) was bracket-mounted
to the ceiling to cover the entire six-pen area (2.44 m × 3.66 m).
One time-lapse video recorder (Samsung SLV-960A; Kyungki Do, Korea)
per chamber was used to continuously record behavior in 24-hour
time-lapse mode (2.78 mm tape per second, 12:1 compression). The
four pigs in each pen were marked with an animal crayon marker
(stripes, shoulder belts, spots, no marking) to allow for
identification of individual pigs. Behavior data were analyzed on a
per-pen basis using 10-minute scan sampling intervals for body
positions and 5-minute scan sampling intervals for feeding
behavior.17 Measured behaviors were directly entered
from the video recordings into a computer spreadsheet.18
The list of measured behaviors (ethogram) included three
categories: upright posture, defined as the pig assuming or
maintaining an upright position on extended legs while standing
still or moving; recumbency, the default behavior; and feeding
behavior, measured and defined as the pig’s head positioned
in the feeder. Data were expressed for each behavior category as
its percentage of total observation time. Such data are generally
not normally distributed. Therefore, the arcsine transformation was
applied to the square roots of percentage data to achieve normal
distribution before further parametric statistical
analysis.18
Performance (Experiment One)
Measures related to growth performance were BW (kg per pen) and
ADG (kg per pen). Individual BW was measured using a portable
electronic scale (accuracy ± 0.02 kg). Measurements of feed
intake (as fed) were attempted by collecting feed refusals from the
feeders and floor and subtracting them from feed provided to the
pigs. As feed residuals partly fell through the slatted floor where
they mixed with excreta, feed refusals were not measured and feed
efficiency could not be calculated.
Statistical analyses
Behavior, BW, and blood analyses-related data were analyzed as a
split-plot for repeated measures (for day in Experiment One or time
in Experiment Two) using PROC MIXED in SAS (SAS Institute Inc,
Cary, North Carolina). The model included treatment (tested with
pen-within-chamber variance), effects of day in Experiment One or
time in Experiment Two, and the interaction of treatment × day (or
time) in the subplot. Average-daily-gain data were analyzed using
PROC GLM. The model included treatment and pen-within-chamber as
the error term.
Results
Experiment One: prolonged NH3 exposure studies
Hematology, biochemistry, and NH3 measurements. Absolute
blood cell counts (Figure 1) and results for cortisol and
haptoglobin assays (Figure 2) are expressed as least squares means.
Prolonged exposure to atmospheric NH3 affected absolute blood cell
counts (Figure 1). On Day 19, WBC and absolute numbers of
lymphocytes and monocytes in pigs exposed to 35 ppm NH3 were
approximately twice those in the control animals. Blood cell counts
did not differ between groups exposed to 0 and 50 ppm NH3.
Hemoglobin, MCV, MCH, and MCHC were similar for control groups and
those exposed to NH3 (ranges 100 to 160 g per L, 50 to 68 fL, 17 to
23 pg, and 300 to 360 g per L, respectively). Concentrations
of blood metabolites and plasma NH3 were similar in controls and
pigs exposed to NH3 (BUN range, 3.3 to 3.6 mmol per L; glucose
range, 4.9 to 5.3 mmol per L; lactate range, 5.29 to
6.84 mmol per L; NH3 range 25.7 to 47.0 μg per
dL).
| Figure 1: White blood cell counts (least squares
means) in nursery pigs exposed to atmospheric ammonia for 19 days at 0
versus 35 ppm (panels A through D) and at 0 versus 50 ppm atmospheric ammonia
(panels E through H) (Experiment One; chronic exposure). Pigs weaned at
10 days of age were housed four per pen, with pen the experimental unit
(six pens and 24 pigs per treatment). Exposure to ammonia began 10 days
post weaning when the pigs were 29 days old (Day 0). Samples from one pig
per pen were tested on Days -1, 7, and 19 (n = 6). Values within a panel
with different letters differ (P < .05; ANOVA). Day 7 data for
pigs on 50 ppm ammonia are missing because whole blood samples were unintentionally
discarded.

|
| Figure 2: Serum cortisol and haptoglobin concentrations
(least squares means) in nursery pigs (described in Figure 1) exposed to
atmospheric ammonia at 0 versus 35 ppm (panels A and B) and 0 versus 50
ppm (panels C and D) at Days -1, 7, and 19 (Experiment One; n = 24). Values
within a panel with different letters differ (P < .05; ANOVA).

|
Serum cortisol, haptoglobin, and TNF-α.
Serum cortisol concentrations were greater on Day 19 (P <
.05) in pigs exposed to either 35 or 50 ppm NH3 than in control
animals (Figure 2). Additionally, haptoglobin was higher on Days 7
and 19 (P < .05) in pigs exposed to 50 ppm NH3 than in
controls. Tumor necrosis factor-α was similar across
treatments (range, 31 to 60 pg per mL).
Performance. Initial mean BW (Day 0) (± standard error
of the mean [SEM]) were 9.95 ± 0.57 kg (Study 1) and 7.50 ±
0.32 kg (Study 2). On Day 19, BW of pigs exposed to 35 ppm
NH3 (19.4 ± 0.95 kg) and control pigs (19.1 ± 0.95 kg) did not differ (P > .05; Study
1), and BW of pigs exposed to 50 ppm NH3 (12.4 ± 0.81 kg)
and control pigs (12.9 ± 0.81 kg) did not differ (P >
.05; Study 2). Accordingly, ADG did not differ between treatments
in either study.
Behavior. Body posture, feeding, and aggressive behaviors
on Day 2 were similar in pigs exposed to NH3 and control pigs.
However, on Day 18, time spent feeding was less (mean + SEM) in
pigs exposed to 50 ppm NH3 (11.27% ± 1.29% of time) than in
control animals (12.27% ± 1.29% of time) (P < .05).
Across both studies, the combined average percent feeding time for
the control groups was 12.82% on Day 2 and 11.37% on Day 18.
Finally, for all treatment groups, the range for upright posture
(across both studies and on both observation days) was 30% to 42%
of time, and the range for aggression was 0.4% to 2.2% of time.
Experiment Two: acute NH3 exposure studies
Cortisol, haptoglobin, and TNF-α.
Serum cortisol was greater in pigs exposed to 35 ppm NH3 than in
controls after 12 hours (P < .05), and tended to be
greater after 24 hours (P = .07) and 48 hours (P =
.08; Figure 3). Acute exposure to NH3 did not affect serum
haptoglobin or plasma TNF-α concentrations (Figure 3).
| Figure 3: Serum cortisol, haptoglobin, and tumor
necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) in nursery pigs acutely exposed to
ammonia gas at 0 ppm versus 35 ppm and at 0 ppm versus 50 ppm for 96 hours
(least squares means; Experiment Two). Blood samples collected from six
pigs per treatment (one per pen) at 72 hours before and 2, 8, 12, 24, 48,
and 96 hours after ammonia exposure began were tested (n = 6). * Control
and treatment values differ (P < .05; ANOVA); †Control
and treatment values tend to differ (P < .10 ANOVA).

|
Discussion
The role of NH3 in development of respiratory disease remains
unclear, although it acts synergistically with other pollutants and
may influence the incidence and severity of pathogen-induced
respiratory diseases.19 Ammonia is highly soluble in
water and is presumably largely absorbed by the distal airway
mucus. Ammonia can favor bacterial contamination of the lungs by
decreasing pulmonary clearance and inducing airway mucosal
inflammation.20-22 Ammonia also can affect cellular
necrosis of alveolar tissues and lead to respiratory stress and
edema. Stress in general has effects on immune, endocrine,
behavior, and performance measures.23 Stress factors
induce a series of natural defense reactions, which constitute
homeostatic processes. The early phase of airway mucosal
inflammation elicits an acute-phase response. Among the most
prominent acute-phase responses is an increase in liver-synthesized
serum proteins, ie, acute phase proteins, which are believed to
play a vital role in the physiological stress response.4
Haptoglobin, an acute phase protein, plays a vital role in the
restoration of homeostasis after injury, tissue necrosis, and
infection by scavenging heme released by damaged cells. Increased
serum concentrations of haptoglobin are also indicative of
inflammatory or infectious lesions.24 Haptoglobin is
generally regarded as being a sensitive, although non-specific,
indicator of stress and is used to assess health in
pigs.25 Grellner et al26 suggested that serum
concentrations of acute phase protein in pigs are negatively
correlated with BW, indicating that a prolonged activated cellular
immune response is a detriment to growth. In our study, mean serum
haptoglobin concentration of pigs exposed to 50 ppm of NH3 was
twice that of their peers in the control chamber. This high
haptoglobin concentration on Days 7 and 19 might indicate that the
pigs exposed to 50 ppm of NH3 did not adapt to or recover from the
gas stimulus, but invested significantly in the cleanup of cell
debris. A continuing high haptoglobin concentration might indicate
pulmonary edema or continuing alveolar necrosis; however, pigs
exposed to 35 ppm did not show greater serum haptoglobin
concentrations than the controls, which may indicate that these
pigs detoxified after the initial insult. A combination of serum
haptaglobin and serum cortisol concentrations may be a more
reliable indicator of disease status or stress in pigs than either
measurement alone.3 Interestingly, our experiments
showed a tendency for pigs exposed to NH3 to have higher serum
cortisol concentrations not only in the acute but also in the
prolonged studies (Day 19). This is in contrast to the results of
another study,27 which showed no cortisol response to
exposure to concentrations of 25 to 100 ppm of atmospheric NH3 over
a 6-day period.
Cytokines mediate a variety of local and systemic biological
functions involved in the control of acute phase protein
expression.2 Ammonia causes the release of cytokines by
alveolar macrophages and neutrophils, constituting an inflammatory
response.3 Correlations of haptoglobin and plasma
TNF-α with prolonged stress were reported
earlier.28 Our studies did not show a response of the
cytokine TNF-α to prolonged or acute exposure to NH3, which
may be explained by the large degree of variation in this
parameter. In addition to cytokines and acute phase proteins, high
total WBC count and absolute numbers of macrophages, neutrophils,
and lymphocytes are considered indicators of immunological
responses to respiratory stress.1 In the present
studies, pigs exposed to NH3 at 35 ppm, compared to the controls,
had much higher total WBC and absolute numbers of lymphocytes and
monocytes, but numbers of neutrophils did not differ between
treated and control groups. Absolute numbers of lymphocytes and
monocytes were not consistently increased in groups exposed to 50
ppm in Study 2. We believe that the large degree of variance in
these values masked what we expected to be significant differences
(as exhibited in Study 1; exposure to 35 ppm).
The present experimental design followed those of common
pathology and exposure studies11,12 in which multiple
subjects are tested per exposure room or building and the animal or
pen, rather than the room, is considered the experimental unit. In
these studies, pen was the experimental unit, and in Experiment
One, we randomly selected one pig per pen for hematology testing,
considering this randomly selected animal as representative of the
pen of four animals. In addition, we considered the process of
removing individual pigs from the chamber and collecting blood
samples from each pig while separated from the group to be less
stressful than collecting samples from the pigs among their
peers.
It should be noted that the treatment (ammonia concentration)
was applied continuously in each ammonia treatment room in all four
studies. In future studies, a larger sample size (ie, more pen
replications) might be advantageous to increase statistical power,
thereby addressing the issue of large variability, to determine
whether similar effects occur in pigs exposed to NH3 at 50 and 35
ppm.
Previous research in nursery pigs has suggested that
pro-inflammatory cytokines correlate with low feed intake and
growth.6 Additionally, Drummond et al20
compared effects of 50, 100, and 150 ppm NH3 versus the control (0
ppm) on performance and reported ADG was lower by 12%, 30%, and
29%, respectively, compared to the controls. Our studies comparing
pigs exposed to NH3 at 0 and 35 ppm and at 0 and 50 ppm did not
detect effects on performance, other than a trend toward low dry
matter intake at 50 ppm NH3 exposure. These results agree with
those of others,8 who found no effects of chronic NH3
exposure (up to 37 ppm NH3) on productivity of weaned pigs > 5.5
weeks of age.
Animal behavior is regarded as a sensitive indicator of what an
animal prefers or
dislikes. Morrison et al29 concluded that NH3
concentrations in commercial buildings are not sufficient to induce
aversion to NH3. Although the experiment at hand does not address
ammonia aversion and preferences, more recent preference
tests30,31 indicate that weanling pigs did prefer to
avoid an area where NH3 was ≥ 20 ppm, but this avoidance
was delayed and explained by the possible development of a general
sense of malaise. Even operant responses of pigs to high
concentrations of NH3 (up to 100 ppm) revealed a relatively
weak aversion to polluted air exposure while they were rooting for
food.32 Although the concept of malaise in the context
of motivational studies was not the question of concern in our
work, one might expect that subclinically diseased pigs would
decrease their feeding behavior (frequency and duration of feeding
bouts) at NH3 concentrations that were previously reported to
affect the behavior of pigs. Our results, however, supported that
hypothesis only at 50 ppm and not at 35 ppm NH3 exposure. Pigs and
other species typically reduce their overall activity during
periods of inflammation, which is referred to as sickness
behavior.33 The lack of a difference in upright body
postures between pigs exposed to 35 or 50 ppm and untreated pigs in
Experiment One does not support the interpretation that pigs
exposed to these NH3 concentrations experienced a state of
sickness.
Current recommendations on upper NH3 limits are mainly intended
to provide occupational exposure limits, as the scientific evidence
that NH3 exposure affects animal health and performance is
scarce.8,34 Synergistic effects of dust and NH3 on swine
health35,36 and on occupational health of farm workers
35,37 have been reported and need to be considered
accordingly. Recent studies failed to find an effect of a 5-week
chronic exposure to NH3 (≤ 37 ppm) on respiratory disease in
weaned pigs.36,37 Even after exposure to combinations of
dust and NH3, gross pathology was minimal and widespread minor
pathological changes were of little significance.36 Most
existing guidelines and recommendations for animal houses set
limits ranging from 20 to 50 ppm of NH3. Our studies indicate that
pigs respond to NH3 with systemic stress responses; however, even
50 ppm does not affect animal growth performance over a 20-day
period. Future studies should focus on the effects of NH3 on lung
histopathology to determine the kind of damage occuring due to NH3
exposure that elicits the animal’s physiological stress
response.
Implications
- Under the conditions of this study, prolonged exposure of
weaned pigs to atmospheric NH3 elicits increases in WBC, absolute
numbers of lymphocytes and monocytes, and serum cortisol and
haptoglobin.
- Under the conditions of this study, exposure to NH3 at
concentrations of up to 50 ppm does not affect weight gain of
pigs.
- Reduced feeding behavior at exposure to 50 ppm NH3 implies that
prolonged exposure (in combination with other factors) should be
studied on a larger number of pigs.
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by the National Pork Board, Grant
#03–159. The authors acknowledge the support for E. von
Borell via a fellowship under the OECD Cooperative Research Program
“Biological Resource Management for Sustainable Agriculture
Systems.” The authors thank K. Parker, L. McDonnell, E.
Veenendaal, and Leticia Valadez for their assistance.
References
1. Asmar S, Pickrell JA, Oehme FW. Pulmonary diseases caused by
airborne contaminants in swine confinement buildings. Vet Hum
Toxicol. 2001;43:48–53.
2. Kataranovski M, Magic Z, Pejnovic N. Early inflammatory
cytokine and acute phase protein response under the stress of
thermal injury in rats. Physiol Res.
1999;48:473–482.
3. Murata H, Horino R. Effects of in vitro atmospheric ammonia
exposure on recovery rate and luminol-dependent chemiluminescence
of bovine neutrophils and bronchoalveolar macrophages. J Vet Med
Sci. 1999;61:279–281.
4. Weissman C. The metabolic response to stress: an overview and
update. Anesthesiol. 1990;73:308–327.
5. Tuchscherer M, Puppe B, Tuchscherer A, Kanitz E. Effects of
social status after mixing on immune, metabolic, and endocrine
responses in pigs. Physiol Behav. 1998;64:353–360.
6. Spurlock ME. Regulation of metabolism and growth during
immune challenge: An overview of cytokine function. J Anim
Sci. 1997;75:1773–1783.
7. Alder RG. Ammonia in workplace atmospheres – solid
sorbent. 2002. Available at: www.osha.gov/dts/sltc/methods/inorganic/id188/id188.html.
Accessed 23 Jan 2007.
8. Wathes CM, Demmers TGM, Teer N, White RP, Taylor LL, Bland V,
Jones P, Armstrong D, Gresham ACJ, Hartung J, Chennells DJ, Done
SH. Production of weaned pigs after chronic exposure to airborne
dust and ammonia. Anim Sci. 2004;78:87–97.
9. Cox DR. Planning of Experiments. New York: Wiley;
1958.
10. Aron DK, Hays VW. How many pigs? Statistical power
considerations in swine nutritional experiments. J Anim Sci.
2004;82:245–254.
11. Williams NH, Stahly TS, Zimmerman DR. Effects of level of
chronic immune system activation on the growth and dietary lysine
needs of pigs fed from 6 to 112 kg. J Anim Sci.
1997;75:2463–2471.
12. Lee C, Giles LR, Bryden WL, Downing JL, Owens PC, Kirby AC,
Wynn PC. Performance and endocrine responses of group housed weaner
pigs exposed to the air quality of a commercial environment.
Livest Prod Sci. 2005;93:255–262.
13. Webber ME, MacDonald T, Pushkarsky MB, Patel CK, Zhao Y,
Marcillac N, Mitloehner FM. Agricultural ammonia sensor using diode
lasers and photoacoustic spectroscopy. Meas Sci Technol.
2005;16:1–7.
14. Myers MJ, Farrell DE, Palmer DC, Post LO. Inflammatory
mediator production in swine following endotoxin challenge with or
without co-administration of dexamethasone. Int
Immunopharmacol. 2003;3:571–579.
15. Petersen HH, Nielsen JP, Jensen AJ, Heegoard PM. Evaluation
of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for determination of
porcine haptoglobin. J Vet Med A. 2001;48:513–523.
16. Daley CA, Sakuria H, Adams BM, Adams TE. Effect of
stress-like concentrations of cortisol on gonadotroph function in
orchidectomized sheep. Biol Reprod.
1999;60:158–163.
17. Martin P, Bateson P. Measuring Behaviour: An Introductory
Guide. 2nd ed. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press;
1993.
18. Mitlohner FM, Morrow-Tesch JL, Wilson SC, Dailey JW, McGlone
JJ. Behavioral sampling techniques for feedlot cattle. J Anim
Sci. 2001;79:1189–1193.
19. Hamilton TDC, Roe JM, Hayes CM, Jones P, Pearson GR, Webster
AFJ. Contributory and exacerbating roles of gaseous ammonia and
organic dust in the etiology of atrophic rhinitis. Clin Diagn
Lab Immunol. 1999;6:199–203.
20. Drummond JG, Curtis SE, Simon J, Norton HW. Effects of
aerial ammonia on growth and health of young pigs. J Anim
Sci. 1980;50:1085–1091.
21. Drummond JG, Curtis SE, Simon J, Norton HW. Effects of
atmospheric ammonia on young pigs infected with Bordetella
bronchiseptica. Am J Vet Res. 1981;42:963–968.
22. Drummond JG, Curtis SE, Meyer RC, Simon J, Norton HW.
Effects of atmospheric ammonia on young pigs experimentally
infected with Ascaris suum. Am J Vet Res.
1981;42:969–974.
23. Hicks TA, McGlone JJ, Whisnant CS, Kattesh HG, Norman RL.
Behavioral, endocrine, immune and performance measures for pigs
exposed to acute stress. J Anim Sci.
1998;76:475–483.
24. Lampreave F, Gonzalez-Ramon N, Martinez-Ayensa S, Hernandez
MA, Lorenzo HK, Garcia-Gil A, Pineiro A. Characterization of the
acute phase serum protein response in pigs. Electrophoresis.
1994;15:672–676.
25. Eckersall PD, Saini PK, McComb C. The acute phase response
of acid soluble glycoprotein, alpha-acid glycoprotein,
ceruloplasmin, haptoglobin, and C-reactive protein in the pig.
Vet Immunol Immunopathol. 1996;51:377–385.
26. Grellner GF, Fangman TM, Caroll JA, Wiedmeyer CE. Using
serology in combination with acute phase proteins and cortisol to
determine stress and immune function of early-weaned pigs. J
Swine Health Prod. 2002;10:199–204.
27. Gustin P, Urbain B, Prouvost JF, Ansay M. Effects of
atmospheric ammonia on pulmonary hemodynamics and vascular
permeability in pigs: Interaction with endotoxins. Toxicol Appl
Pharmacol. 1994;125:17–26.
28. Harding JC, Baarsch MJ, Murtaugh MP. Association of tumor
necrosis factor and acute phase reactant changes with post arrival
disease in swine. J Vet Med B. 1997;44:405–413.
29. Morrison WD, Pirie PP, Perkins S, Braithwaite LA, Smith JH,
Waterfall D, Doucett CM. Gases and respirable dust in confinement
buildings and the responses of animals to such airborne
contaminants. In: Collins E, Boon C, eds. Livestock Environment
IV. Fourth International Symposium. St Joseph, Michigan:
American Society of Agricultural Engineers; 1993:734–741.
30. Jones JB, Burgess LR, Webster AJF, Wathes CM. Behavioural
responses of pigs to atmospheric ammonia in a chronic choice test.
Anim Sci. 1996;63:437–445.
31. Wathes CM, Jones JB, Kristensen HH, Jones EKM, Webster AJF.
Aversion of pigs and domestic fowl to atmospheric ammonia. Trans
Am Soc Agric Eng. 2002;45:1605–1610.
32. Jones JB, Burgess LR, Webster AJF, Wathes CM. Operant
responses of pigs to atmospheric ammonia. Appl Anim Behav
Sci. 1998;58:35–47.
33. Johnson RW, von Borell E. Lipopolysaccharide-induced
sickness behavior in pigs is inhibited by pretreatment with
indomethacin. J Anim Sci. 1994;72:309–314.
34. Donham KJ. Association of environmental air contaminants
with disease and productivity in swine. Am J Vet Res.
1991;52:1723–1730.
35. Donham KJ, Leininger JR. Animal studies of potential chronic
lung disease of workers in swine confinement buildings. Am J Vet
Res. 1984;45:926–931.
36. Done SH, Gresham ACJ, Williamson S, Hunt B, Chennells DJ,
White RP, Demmers TGM, Teer N, Wathes CM, Taylor L, Bland V, Jones
P, Armstrong D. The pathological findings in pigs exposed to aerial
pollutants. Pig J. 2003;51:119–130.
37. Done SH, Chennells DJ, Gresham ACJ, Williamson S, Taylor LJ,
Bland V, Hunt B, Jones P, Armstrong D, White RP, Demmers TGM, Teer
N, Wathes CM. Clinical and pathological responses of weaned pigs to
ammonia and dust. Vet Rec. 2005;157:70–80.
|
|